Fish Eaters Traditional Catholic Forum
April 23, 2014, 07:21:PM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length

News: So, Pavlov's sitting in a bar enjoying a pint. The phone rings. He jumps up and says, "Dang! I forgot to feed the dog!"
 
   Fish Eaters    Forum Index   Forum Rules   Help Calendar Members Chat Room   Who's Chatting   Login Register  
Pages: [1]
 
Author Topic: Difference between judging and having an opinion  (Read 1744 times)
Pilgrim_here
Member

Posts: 242


« on: September 19, 2011, 04:08:AM »

So I'm confused about this question and it's been bugging me for years.

What's the difference between setting myself up as a judge of my fellow man (i.e. condemned by scripture) and thinking that what someone is doing is wrong?

Is it just that the former involves thinking of yourself as better than that person?

P.S.  I hope this is in the right forum - seems like a theological question to me.............
« Last Edit: September 19, 2011, 04:13:AM by Pilgrim_here » Logged
newyorkcatholic
Member

Gender: Male
Location: New York, NY, USA
Posts: 4,608


terrena despicere


« Reply #1 on: September 19, 2011, 10:06:AM »

So I'm confused about this question and it's been bugging me for years.

What's the difference between setting myself up as a judge of my fellow man (i.e. condemned by scripture) and thinking that what someone is doing is wrong?

Is it just that the former involves thinking of yourself as better than that person?

P.S.  I hope this is in the right forum - seems like a theological question to me.............

Here's my understanding.

We can judge basic outward actions.  This is pretty straightforward sometimes, but circumstances can get complex. But we have to.  What if you are a judge?  What if you are teaching your children right and wrong?  What if you are on a Church tribunal?

But we never judge someone's heart, whether they are in the state of grace, what their end shall be.  That is for God alone.
Logged

One human thought alone is worth more than the entire world, hence God alone is worthy of it. -- St. John of the Cross
Mithrandylan
Banned for promoting sedevacantism
Regular

Gender: Male
Location: Tundra
Personality type: Melancholy- a point below phlegmatic
Posts: 10,141


Divínum auxílium ✝ maneat semper nobíscum.


« Reply #2 on: September 19, 2011, 10:10:AM »

One of the problems is that culture has a very poor understanding of what it means "to judge."  Essentially, if you point out anything unfavorable about anything or anyone you are judging them.

To judge is a very specific act.  We judge when we say someone is going to hell (but remember that describing a behavior as something that leads one to hell isn't judging) or that they are scum or make any personal evaluation of them as a person.

As far as their actions, those can and must be evaluated.
Logged
ResiduumRevertetur
Gold Fish
*
Gender: Female
Location: Southern Maryland
Personality type: E/INTJ
Posts: 5,084



« Reply #3 on: September 19, 2011, 10:11:AM »


But we never judge someone's heart, whether they are in the state of grace, what their end shall be.  That is for God alone.
I think this says it very well.
Logged

The name's Braintrust. Mr. Braintrust.

The Almighty says this must be a fashionable fight. It's drawn the finest people. --Stephen, Braveheart
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Deus, tu conversus vivificabis nos, et plebs tua laetabitur in te.
Pilgrim_here
Member

Posts: 242


« Reply #4 on: September 19, 2011, 01:12:PM »

Got it - thanks for all the replies
Logged


Pages: [1]
 
 
Jump to:  

Powered by SMF 1.1.8 | SMF © 2006-2008, Simple Machines LLC