Fish Eaters Traditional Catholic Forum
May 18, 2013, 05:41:AM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News: The man still needs help!
 
   Fish Eaters    Forum Index   Forum Rules   Help Calendar Members Chat Room   Who's Chatting   Login Register  
Poll
Question: Should this forum be closed down? If so, why? If not, why not?  (Voting closed: January 24, 2012, 11:18:PM)
Yes. It has ceased to serve Christ. - 7 (4.3%)
No. It serves Christ. - 46 (28.6%)
If I had to pay for and run it, I'd close it down. - 4 (2.5%)
If I had to pay for and run it, I'd keep it up anyway, despite the headaches and costs, even if I rarely posted here myself.. - 6 (3.7%)
I think it should stay up if ___explain below___ - 4 (2.5%)
The FE site is fine, but the forum should go. - 10 (6.2%)
Yes, there are too many mean people here, too much gang-banging, too much bigotry. - 5 (3.1%)
The forum is too tightly moderated so that things the moderator considers "bigoted" and such are too tightly defined. - 2 (1.2%)
If it were up to me to run it, I'd close it, but I'm glad someone else runs it and that it's there. - 4 (2.5%)
This forum is the best thing to happen to the internet since Google (ha). - 27 (16.8%)
This forum is mostly a cesspool -- but I still like it. - 3 (1.9%)
This forum is mostly a cesspool -- to the point I think it should go. - 3 (1.9%)
The forum used to be good, but now it sucks because ___explain below___ - 4 (2.5%)
This forum is a good thing for people who are interested in Catholicism to see (explain why below). - 11 (6.8%)
This forum hurts the cause of Catholicism (explain why below). - 3 (1.9%)
I really don't care. - 0 (0%)
I care, but wouldn't blame you at all for closing it down. Must be expensive and a pain. - 22 (13.7%)
Total Voters: 101

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 [9] 10 11 12 13 14
 
Author Topic: Should this forum be closed down?  (Read 3913 times)
Tim
Gold Fish
*
Gender: Male
Location: chicago
Posts: 12,296



« Reply #80 on: January 23, 2012, 08:59:AM »

I understand the issues around using your actual name, but the taking on of an online persona is a problem for many.  What about using an old nick name ? The idea being "be what you is and not what you ain't." I can't remember the character on Rocky and Bullwinkle but it's a very good idea. For instance mine as a young guy until I was a grown man was Tutto. It's Italian for all. I'm sure you all have one.

The other issue is brnging down the men in black on Vox. We should be able to write comments without being inflamatory or  anti-semitic or racist. We should be able with seeing Sebelius' edict concerning the pill etc., that we are being singled out for persecution. Let's not give them ammo. There are thirteen internet Catholic organizations which have come to be called the "dirty dozen". They were singled out as possible right wing home grown terrorists. Many of us are on those lists, let's not end up in Fema camps, huh, please ?

tim
Logged
StrictCatholicGirl
Gold Fish
*
Posts: 11,258


Downton Addict


« Reply #81 on: January 23, 2012, 09:44:AM »

In addition to what I said on page 3 or 4, I would hate to see the forum close down just as I'm 13... er, 12 posts away from the big 10,000!!
Logged

"We are afraid of God's surprises." -- Pope Francis
StrictCatholicGirl
Gold Fish
*
Posts: 11,258


Downton Addict


« Reply #82 on: January 23, 2012, 09:44:AM »

11....
Logged

"We are afraid of God's surprises." -- Pope Francis
Ol Dirty Papist
Member

Posts: 60



« Reply #83 on: January 23, 2012, 10:36:AM »

Requiring posters to post under their real names could allay much mischief. I'm quite willing to do so. The trouble would be confirming that they are in fact using their real names.

Posting under real names would be very bad professionally for some users.  The early Christians didn't meet in the catacombs for the heck of it. They weren't stupid and weren't seeking their martyrdom. 

A bit melodramatic, don't ya think?

Yours,

Fernando Umberto Garcia

It is a bit melodramatic, but at the same time I don't want anyone showing up to my work place because of a disagreement we had over Marian apparitions.  Also,  what if my boss were gay?  I can't imagine having my name show up on google under a traditional catholic forum would do me any favors. 
Logged
Ol Dirty Papist
Member

Posts: 60



« Reply #84 on: January 23, 2012, 10:37:AM »

I'd either clean house or shut down if it were me.   I wouldn't want to provide a soapbox for disgruntled trads to come and spew their antisemitism and holocaust revisionism.

Says the clown with the anti-Christ as an avatar  Eye-roll

Meh, took it down.   Seems pointless now that the negative fish factor is gone.
Logged


Vox Clamantis
Forum Owner

Gender: Female
Location: Indiana
Personality type: INFJ - Melancholic
Posts: I am a geek!!


"Love and Do What Thou Wilt"


WWW
« Reply #85 on: January 23, 2012, 10:47:AM »

I understand the issues around using your actual name, but the taking on of an online persona is a problem for many.  What about using an old nick name ? The idea being "be what you is and not what you ain't." I can't remember the character on Rocky and Bullwinkle but it's a very good idea. For instance mine as a young guy until I was a grown man was Tutto. It's Italian for all. I'm sure you all have one.

The other issue is brnging down the men in black on Vox. We should be able to write comments without being inflamatory or  anti-semitic or racist. We should be able with seeing Sebelius' edict concerning the pill etc., that we are being singled out for persecution. Let's not give them ammo. There are thirteen internet Catholic organizations which have come to be called the "dirty dozen". They were singled out as possible right wing home grown terrorists. Many of us are on those lists, let's not end up in Fema camps, huh, please ?

tim

Yeah, that's a funny thing about all this sort of thing. Say the way-wacky "right-wing extremist," bigot, skinhead, Nazi, truly tin-foil hat types are right: so they're talking their stuff all over my forum -- and guess who'd get to go to the camp? ME! Oh, boy! Like I want to go to a FEMA camp because of someone else who can't watch his big mouth. Great! Not very chivalrous of these self-appointed knights LOL
Logged
Someone1776
"The Derailer"
Member

Posts: 10,405


Neo-Candylander


« Reply #86 on: January 23, 2012, 11:07:AM »

I understand the issues around using your actual name, but the taking on of an online persona is a problem for many.  What about using an old nick name ? The idea being "be what you is and not what you ain't." I can't remember the character on Rocky and Bullwinkle but it's a very good idea. For instance mine as a young guy until I was a grown man was Tutto. It's Italian for all. I'm sure you all have one.

The other issue is brnging down the men in black on Vox. We should be able to write comments without being inflamatory or  anti-semitic or racist. We should be able with seeing Sebelius' edict concerning the pill etc., that we are being singled out for persecution. Let's not give them ammo. There are thirteen internet Catholic organizations which have come to be called the "dirty dozen". They were singled out as possible right wing home grown terrorists. Many of us are on those lists, let's not end up in Fema camps, huh, please ?

tim

Yeah, that's a funny thing about all this sort of thing. Say the way-wacky "right-wing extremist," bigot, skinhead, Nazi, truly tin-foil hat types are right: so they're talking their stuff all over my forum -- and guess who'd get to go to the camp? ME! Oh, boy! Like I want to go to a FEMA camp because of someone else who can't watch his big mouth. Great! Not very chivalrous of these self-appointed knights LOL

ROFL
Logged

"Christianity lies in achieving greatness in the face of the world's hatred." - Saint Ignatius of Antioch
Hanno
Member

Gender: Male
Posts: 364


Having conquered the Orient


« Reply #87 on: January 23, 2012, 11:53:AM »

It is a bit melodramatic, but at the same time I don't want anyone showing up to my work place because of a disagreement we had over Marian apparitions.  Also,  what if my boss were gay?  I can't imagine having my name show up on google under a traditional catholic forum would do me any favors. 

Aren't we supposed to speak the truth, publicly, whether it wins us any favors or not?

"Traditional Catholicism" is Catholicism.  It is Christianity.  We should no more fear being numbered as traditional Catholics as we should fear being called a Christian.  If a gay boss fires us for being Catholic, then we should accept it as the price we pay for proclaiming our faith in a world that hates it.
Logged

"A race dissolved in every passion, destroyed by uncontrolled self-indulgence, cringing and womanish in its thinking, close to cowardice, wallowing in all swinishness, debased, content with servitude in security, such is the life of those who belong to the present generation."  —St. Athanasius
Someone1776
"The Derailer"
Member

Posts: 10,405


Neo-Candylander


« Reply #88 on: January 23, 2012, 11:55:AM »

It is a bit melodramatic, but at the same time I don't want anyone showing up to my work place because of a disagreement we had over Marian apparitions.  Also,  what if my boss were gay?  I can't imagine having my name show up on google under a traditional catholic forum would do me any favors. 

Aren't we supposed to speak the truth, publicly, whether it wins us any favors or not?

"Traditional Catholicism" is Catholicism.  It is Christianity.  We should no more fear being numbered as traditional Catholics as we should fear being called a Christian.  If a gay boss fires us for being Catholic, then we should accept it as the price we pay for proclaiming our faith in a world that hates it.

The Early Christians were cowards for meeting in the catacombs. They should have all run around Rome proudly saying they were Christians and tried holding mass in the Roman forum. 
Logged

"Christianity lies in achieving greatness in the face of the world's hatred." - Saint Ignatius of Antioch
Mithrandylan
Banned for promoting sedevacantism
Regular

Gender: Male
Location: Tundra
Personality type: Melancholy- a point below phlegmatic
Posts: 10,141


Divínum auxílium ✝ maneat semper nobíscum.


« Reply #89 on: January 23, 2012, 11:59:AM »

It is a bit melodramatic, but at the same time I don't want anyone showing up to my work place because of a disagreement we had over Marian apparitions.  Also,  what if my boss were gay?  I can't imagine having my name show up on google under a traditional catholic forum would do me any favors. 

Aren't we supposed to speak the truth, publicly, whether it wins us any favors or not?

"Traditional Catholicism" is Catholicism.  It is Christianity.  We should no more fear being numbered as traditional Catholics as we should fear being called a Christian.  If a gay boss fires us for being Catholic, then we should accept it as the price we pay for proclaiming our faith in a world that hates it.

The Early Christians were cowards for meeting in the catacombs. They should have all run around Rome proudly saying they were Christians and tried holding mass in the Roman forum. 

And not until Vatican II did we again see such a blatant display of Christianity being practiced with concern for the world around it.
Logged
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 [9] 10 11 12 13 14
 
 
Jump to:  

Powered by SMF 1.1.8 | SMF © 2006-2008, Simple Machines LLC