Then why is the super offensive video still up? This seems to be the main concern over all the drama here.
Because I haven't taken it down.
And if you care to answer, why were they kicked out of the seminary? For having actual Catholic views? Or were they gossiping and exhibiting behavior unbecoming a future priest?
For lacking prudence. As I said, politically incorrect things can be discussed without needlessly offending people, without turning them off before they even give your message an ear, without making the truth look nasty by associating it with things most people have a knee-jerk negative reaction to, and, most especially, it can be coated in CHARITY and a concern for souls. Seriously, I think some trads around here think it'd be perfectly fine to walk up to less-than-attractive women and say, "You're UGLY!" because "it's true!" Or quote a Klansman who, like a broken clock, was right once in a while when they could perfectly well have quoted another person who wouldn't needlessly inflame situations and turn people off because "he's right!" It's beyond ridiculous. It's stupid. And worst of all, when this sort of thing is done on a Catholic forum, it keeps souls from CHRIST. If you want that sort of thing on your conscience, start your own forum; I don't want it on MY conscience.